Native and non-native listeners' perception of English consonants in different types of noise

This paper shows that the effect of different types of noise on recognition of different phonemes by native versus non-native listeners is highly variable, even within classes of phonemes with the same manner or place of articulation. In a phoneme identification experiment, English and Dutch listeners heard all 24 English consonants in VCV stimuli in quiet and in three types of noise: competing talker, speech­ shaped noise, and modulated speech-shaped noise (all with SNRs of —6 dB). Differential effects of noise type for English and Dutch lis­ teners were found for eight consonants (/p t k g m n q r/) but not for the other 16 consonants. For those eight consonants, effects were again highly variable: each noise type hindered non-native listeners more than native listeners for some of the target sounds, but none of the noise types did so for all of the target sounds, not even for phonemes with the same manner or place of articulation. The results imply that the noise types employed will strongly affect the outcomes of any study of native and non-native speech perception in noise. © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.